← Back to Perspective

26 October 2026 · 5 min read

Why Customer Journeys Break Down Between Teams

Customers experience one journey, but businesses often manage it as a series of disconnected departmental activities. When teams focus on their own targets rather than the overall customer experience, opportunities are lost, costs increase and performance suffers.

The customer sees one business. The business sees several departments.

Most businesses understand the importance of delivering a good customer journey. They invest in marketing, sales teams, processes and technology to attract customers and convert their interest into business.

Yet customer journeys still break down.

Why? Because although the customer experiences one journey, the business often manages it across several departments, each with its own objectives, targets and measures of success.

Marketing wants to generate enquiries. Sales wants to convert them. Operations wants to handle demand efficiently. Finance wants to see a return on investment.

None of these objectives is unreasonable. The problem starts when they aren’t aligned, particularly in the grey areas between departments where responsibility and accountability aren’t always clear.

What are the KPIs between marketing and sales? Is marketing measured on the number of leads it generates, the quality of those leads, or the revenue they ultimately produce? And how much responsibility does sales have for the quality of the leads it receives?

If these questions aren’t addressed, each department can end up concentrating on its own targets without fully understanding how its performance affects the wider business.

The customer, meanwhile, experiences one journey, not a series of departmental handovers.

When generating interest doesn't translate into business

Consider a business offering an insurance product with an incentive, such as an Amazon voucher or a free Apple Watch.

The marketing campaign generates plenty of interest. Traffic increases, enquiries come in and the campaign appears successful.

But what happens when customers discover that receiving the incentive means taking out an insurance policy costing £30–£50 a month?

Some may decide the product isn’t right for them. Others may have been more interested in the incentive than the insurance itself.

The customer becomes frustrated after spending time exploring an offer that doesn’t meet their expectations. The adviser spends time speaking to someone who was never particularly interested in the product. Meanwhile, the business has incurred acquisition and handling costs without necessarily generating a sale.

Marketing may have achieved its objective of generating traffic, but has the campaign delivered the outcome the business actually needed?

The answer isn’t necessarily to stop using incentives. It’s to make sure the proposition, the audience and the customer journey work together.

Generating interest is only the beginning. What happens next determines whether that interest becomes valuable business.

The journey should work around the customer

Another example is the online journey that invites customers to ‘Get a Quote’.

You might reasonably expect to receive a quote online. Instead, you enter your details and find yourself in an outbound calling process, with advisers attempting to contact you.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with an outbound sales model. In the right circumstances, a conversation with an adviser may be exactly what a customer needs.

The problem is when the business designs the process around its own operating model rather than the customer’s preferences.

Imagine a customer who is happy to speak to someone but is working during the day. They might say, “If someone could call me this evening at seven, that would be amazing.”

That’s a positive buying signal. The customer is telling the business how to engage with them.

Yet too many processes are designed around making repeated calls when it’s convenient for the business, rather than arranging contact when it suits the customer.

A simple change in approach could improve the customer experience and increase the likelihood of a successful conversation.

The technology and process don’t necessarily need replacing. Sometimes the business simply needs to use them differently.

When departmental targets pull in different directions

The problem becomes more pronounced when leads pass between teams.

Imagine a business working towards a £100,000 revenue target, based on the assumption that generating 1,000 leads will deliver the required result.

But what happens when circumstances change?

The cost of acquiring leads might increase. Customer demand might soften. A previously successful distribution channel might stop delivering the same quality of enquiries.

Marketing responds by finding new sources of leads to maintain the required volume. On paper, the numbers still look achievable. But the new leads don’t convert at the same rate, and the expected revenue fails to materialise.

The pressure then moves to sales, where advisers are challenged on their conversion rates. Marketing argues that it has delivered the leads. Sales argues that the quality isn’t there.

The original budget may have been perfectly reasonable when it was created. But the assumptions underpinning it have changed, and the business needs to recognise that.

Without a shared understanding of what’s happening, the conversation becomes about defending departmental performance rather than addressing the commercial problem.

The management response matters

When performance starts to struggle, I’ve seen too many management conversations become defensive.

The temptation is to apply more pressure: manage the advisers harder, demand more leads or insist that the existing plan is delivered.

But before deciding what needs to change, the business needs to understand what’s actually happening.

If advisers are struggling to convert a new source of leads, for example, the answer isn’t automatically to manage them harder. It might be that the leads have different expectations, the proposition isn’t landing, or the sales approach needs to change.

Gather the data. Listen to the calls. Talk to the people doing the work. Understand what the customer is experiencing.

Then bring the relevant teams together to decide what the evidence is telling you.

This requires an environment where people can openly admit that something isn’t working without feeling they need to defend their department or protect their own targets.

The strongest management teams I’ve seen are those that can have open and honest conversations. They challenge each other’s thinking, focus on understanding the problem and look for a solution rather than deciding who to blame.

The whole journey needs a shared purpose

A good customer journey doesn’t happen simply because every department is doing its own job well. It happens when those departments understand how their decisions affect one another and work towards a common commercial outcome.

That means looking beyond individual KPIs, understanding the quality as well as the quantity of leads, and making sure the processes between teams are as effective as the activities within them.

It also means recognising that the customer doesn’t care how the business is organised internally. They simply want an experience that meets their needs.

Ultimately, the question isn’t whether marketing, sales or operations is responsible for the customer journey. Everyone has a part to play, and the management team has a responsibility to make sure those parts work together.

Strong management teams share in the business’s successes and failures. They celebrate what works, take collective responsibility when things don’t, and focus on what needs to change rather than who needs to take the blame.

After all, there is no ’I’ in team.

If this resonates, I’d be happy to talk it through. Fancy a coffee? →